Choose BrainHQ if long-term brain health is your goal. Its Double Decision exercise is the updated version of the speed training linked to a lower risk of a dementia diagnosis in a 20-year study, though that finding is debated, and some Medicare Advantage plans and public libraries include BrainHQ free. Choose Lumosity if you want varied, polished games you’ll enjoy opening every day; it does not publish its prices, so check what you would pay before you compare.
BrainHQ and Lumosity are the two best-known names in brain training, but they’re built on very different ideas. BrainHQ is a research tool that happens to be an app. Lumosity is a game library designed to keep you coming back. We used both hands-on; here is how they compare, section by section.
| App | Best for | Price (annual) | Rating | Platforms |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| BrainHQ | Strongest research, older adults | $96/yr | 8.6 | iOS, Android, Web |
| Lumosity | Polished variety, free daily games | Not published; top App Store item shown is $89.00 | 7.4 | iOS, Android, Web |
At a glance
| BrainHQ | Lumosity | |
|---|---|---|
| Made by | Posit Science | Lumos Labs |
| Library | 29 exercises in six categories | 40+ games |
| Free every day | Daily Spark: 1 exercise | 3 games, replayable |
| US price | $14/month or $96/year | Not published; $11.99 to $89.00 in App Store |
| Family option | $59 per person per year on a website annual plan | Friends and Family Plan for up to 5 people |
| Refunds | 30 days on website purchases | 30 days on non-monthly plans bought on its website or Google Play |
| Offline play | iPhone and iPad app only | iOS and Android apps |
| Key research | ACTIVE study, with real caveats | A company-run 2015 trial; a 2016 FTC settlement |
What each app trains
BrainHQ has 29 exercises across six categories: attention, brain speed, memory, people skills, intelligence, and navigation. Most are fast perception tasks in which something flashes on screen, or plays through your speakers, for a split second and you report what you noticed. Each one adapts as you go, and a level takes under five minutes. Its Personal Trainer picks your exercises each session, or you can choose them yourself. The best-known exercise, Double Decision, asks you to identify a vehicle in the center of the screen while spotting a road sign in your peripheral vision.
Lumosity has more than 40 games for speed, memory, attention, flexibility, problem-solving, math, and words. You start with a free Fit Test, three games that take about 10 minutes and set your baseline, and Lumosity then builds daily workouts around your results. The games feel like puzzles and arcade challenges rather than lab tasks, and Lumosity shows how your scores compare with others in your age group.
The short version: BrainHQ goes deep on speed and attention, while Lumosity goes wide across many kinds of thinking.
The science
BrainHQ has the strongest evidence of any consumer brain training app. Its Double Decision exercise descends from the speed training used in the ACTIVE study, a large NIH-funded trial of 2,832 older adults; BrainHQ says the ACTIVE version was an earlier form of the same exercise. In a 20-year follow-up published in February 2026, people who did speed training plus at least one booster session had about a 25% lower risk of a dementia diagnosis than the control group (Coe et al., 2026). Three caveats: the benefit appeared only with booster sessions, one study author disclosed financial ties to BrainHQ’s maker, and an independent reanalysis found that no result stayed statistically significant after correcting for multiple comparisons (Dickens, 2026). ACTIVE was also a supervised research program, not an app used at home.
Lumosity reliably makes you better at its own games, and it’s been refined for more than fifteen years. Its best-known study was run by Lumos Labs itself: a 2015 trial in PLOS ONE of 4,715 adults who either trained on Lumosity or did online crossword puzzles for about 15 minutes a day, five days a week, for 10 weeks. The Lumosity group improved more on the study’s tests of processing speed, memory, problem solving, and reasoning. But five of the seven authors worked for Lumos Labs, about half of each group dropped out, and Lumosity’s own summary says more research is needed to connect better test scores to everyday tasks. Our look at brain training vs crosswords covers that comparison in more depth. In 2016, Lumos Labs paid $2 million to settle Federal Trade Commission charges that it made unfounded claims about its games’ cognitive benefits.
For both apps, the wider research is cautious. A major 2016 review by Simons and colleagues found extensive evidence that brain training improves the trained tasks, but little evidence that it improves everyday cognitive performance. The National Institute on Aging says there is not enough evidence that commercial brain training apps have the same impact as the training used in ACTIVE.
Winner: BrainHQ, clearly. See is BrainHQ worth it for the full story on the research.
Price
BrainHQ: $14 a month or $96 a year on its website, which works out to $8 a month on the annual plan; the App Store lists $13.99 and $94.99. Family members can be added to a yearly plan bought on the website for $59 each. Website purchases come with a 30-day refund guarantee, while app store purchases follow Apple’s or Google’s rules. See our BrainHQ cost guide.
Lumosity: does not publish its prices. It shows them only after you sign in, and its US App Store listing shows purchases from $11.99 to $89.00, mostly without naming the plans, so check the purchase page before you pay. It sells monthly, yearly, two-year, and lifetime plans. Its Friends and Family Plan lets one subscriber add four other people, each with their own account. Lumosity offers refunds within 30 days on purchases made on its website or through Google Play, except monthly plans; App Store purchases go through Apple. See our Lumosity cost guide.
Winner: No clear winner without a published Lumosity price. Its top App Store item shown, $89.00, is under BrainHQ’s $96 a year, but Lumosity’s longer plans may cost more, so sign in and check before you compare.
What you get free
BrainHQ gives you one free exercise a day through its Daily Spark, from a different training category each day of the week, and four more exercises are free to try on its homepage. There’s no standard free trial. Full access can be free, though: BrainHQ says many US public libraries offer it to patrons, and its official 2026 list names three Medicare Advantage plans that include it: Elderplan, Kaiser Permanente (Mid-Atlantic), and SummaCare (except its Garnet, Topaz, and Quartz HMO plans). See our BrainHQ free trial guide.
Lumosity gives you three free games a day for as long as you have an account, and you can replay them as often as you like. The games rotate daily and are chosen for you; Premium unlocks all 40-plus games, full five-game workouts, and detailed insights. Lumosity offers trials of Premium at times, though no public page says how long they last or who qualifies. See our Lumosity free trial guide.
Winner: Lumosity for everyday free play; BrainHQ if your library or health plan covers it.
Personalization and progress
BrainHQ’s Personal Trainer lines up about six levels from different exercises in each session, favoring the ones where you have the most room to improve, and moves you on once you hit its performance targets. You can change those targets, set a custom focus, or pick a “Specialized” focus that copies the schedule from a particular study, including ACTIVE. Weekly goals, streaks, and reminders track your effort.
Lumosity builds your daily workout from your Fit Test and your training habits, and Premium adds in-depth insights into your strengths across games plus tips on accuracy, speed, and strategy.
Winner: BrainHQ if you want control over your training; Lumosity if you’d rather open the app and play.
Where you can use them
Both work on iPhone, iPad, Android, and in a web browser, with progress tied to your account. Two differences matter. Lumosity’s apps let you play offline on both iOS and Android, while BrainHQ’s offline option is limited to its iPhone and iPad app, which can download exercise stages ahead of time. And Lumosity’s App Store listing accepts iOS 15 or later, while BrainHQ officially supports only the current and previous versions of iOS and Android.
Winner: Lumosity, narrowly, especially on Android or an older device.
What training feels like
BrainHQ is deliberately slow and adaptive, and its design feels dated. Some exercises work best with your phone turned sideways. It suits people who like steady, focused practice.
Lumosity feels like a game. Its 40-plus games are colorful, quick, and varied, which makes the daily habit easier to keep.
Winner: Lumosity, for most people.
Which should you choose?
Choose BrainHQ if you’re an older adult focused on long-term brain health, you’ll train consistently for months and years, or you can get it free through your Medicare Advantage plan or library. It’s also our top pick among the best brain training apps for seniors.
Choose Lumosity if you mainly want an enjoyable daily mental workout, or you’ll use it on both your phone and computer.
Or start with both for free. BrainHQ’s Daily Spark and Lumosity’s three daily games together give you a fair feel for each before you pay for either.
Other options worth a look
Elevate, $39.99/year. Practical skills like reading, writing, and math. See how it compares in Elevate vs BrainHQ and Lumosity vs Elevate.
For the full rankings, see our best brain training apps roundup.
Zenelia is a brain training app made by Mindkindly’s owner, so we don’t rank or score it here. It costs $6.99 a month or $44.99 a year, has a 7-day free trial, and is iPhone only for now; read more about Zenelia or see it on the App Store.
Common questions
Is BrainHQ better than Lumosity? For research-backed brain health, yes. For an enjoyable daily habit, Lumosity is easier to stick with.
Which is cheaper? We cannot say for sure, because Lumosity does not publish its prices. Its US App Store listing shows purchases from $11.99 to $89.00, and that top item is under BrainHQ’s $96 a year, but Lumosity’s longer plans may cost more. BrainHQ can be free through some Medicare Advantage plans and participating libraries.
Can brain training prevent dementia? No app can promise that. BrainHQ’s speed training was linked to a lower risk of diagnosis over 20 years, but only for people who kept up with booster training, and the finding is still debated. If you or someone close to you is noticing memory changes, talk to a doctor.
Are both on Android? Yes. Both work on iOS, Android, and the web. Only Lumosity’s Android app can be used offline.
Can I share either app with my family? Yes. BrainHQ adds family members to a website annual plan for $59 each, and Lumosity’s Friends and Family Plan covers up to five people aged 13 and older.
Does Lumosity have the same research as BrainHQ? No. Lumosity’s main published trial was run by its own company and lasted 10 weeks. The speed training behind BrainHQ’s Double Decision has follow-up data stretching 20 years, with the caveats above.
The bottom line
BrainHQ is the choice for evidence and long-term brain health, especially if your health plan covers it. Lumosity is the choice for fun and variety. For more, see our BrainHQ review, Lumosity review, and is Lumosity worth it.
Sources
- How are exercises scored? (BrainHQ Support)
- Double Decision (BrainHQ Support)
- The ACTIVE study (BrainHQ)
- How the Personal Trainer picks exercises (BrainHQ Support)
- How do I set up BrainHQ to match a study? (BrainHQ Support)
- BrainHQ subscription plans (BrainHQ Support)
- BrainHQ refund policy (BrainHQ Support)
- What is the Daily Spark? (BrainHQ Support)
- Exercises to try before you buy (BrainHQ Support)
- BrainHQ and Medicare offerings, full list for 2026 (BrainHQ Support)
- BrainHQ for libraries
- Offline training on the BrainHQ app for iOS (BrainHQ Support)
- Offline training on Android (BrainHQ Support)
- System requirements for iOS (BrainHQ Support)
- BrainHQ on the App Store
- Lumosity on the App Store
- Lumosity homepage
- What are the differences between a Free Account and a Premium Membership? (Lumosity Help Center)
- Where are the free games? (Lumosity Help Center)
- How do I take the Fit Test? (Lumosity Help Center)
- What are the types of Lumosity subscriptions available? (Lumosity Help Center)
- What is the cost of a Lumosity subscription? (Lumosity Help Center)
- How do I share Lumosity with family and friends? (Lumosity Help Center)
- How do I get a refund? (Lumosity Help Center)
- Lumosity payment policy
- Can I train offline? (Lumosity Help Center)
- Lumosity to pay $2 million to settle FTC deceptive advertising charges (Federal Trade Commission, 2016)
- Enhancing cognitive abilities with comprehensive training (Hardy et al., PLOS ONE, 2015)
- Impact of cognitive training on claims-based diagnosed dementia over 20 years (Coe et al., 2026)
- Reanalyzing the impact of cognitive training over 20 years in the ACTIVE study (Dickens, 2026)
- Do “brain-training” programs work? (Simons et al., Psychological Science in the Public Interest, 2016)
- Cognitive health and older adults (National Institute on Aging)